Ball Screw or Machine Screw? There are a wide variety of factors which influence the type of actuator selected. When comparing the two actuator types at the same capacity level; Ball Screw actuators, being much more efficient, require less motor horsepower to move the same load than do the equivalent Machine Screw actuators. However, many Machine Screw actuators are inherently load holding, offer a broader capacity range and a greater selection of special features or materials. Machine screw actuators are often favored in applications subject to constant vibration.
Find an actuator model with Capacity greater than the actuator load. Go to the applicable Actuator Performance Specification table and find Turns of Worm for 1" Raise, Worm Torque at No Load, and Worm Torque at Full Load.
Actuator torque(in-lb) = Actuator Load(lbs) x Worm Torque at Full Load
Actuator Capacity (lbs)
For loads less than 25% of actuator capacity, add "Worm torque at no load" to the above calculated torque, to account for frictional losses.
Input RPM = Desired Lifting Speed(in/min) x Turns of Worm for 1" Raise
Actuator Input HP = Actuator torque(in-lb) x rpm
Compare required Input HP to the Maximum HP per Actuator shown in the Performance table. If Required HP exceeds Maximum HP, an actuator with greater HP rating must be chosen to obtain the speed and capacity rating desired.
If using a gear reducer, motor horsepower must be multiplied by reducer efficiency to obtain reducer output (actuator input) horsepower.
Two or more actuators are often shaft driven from one motor or gear reducer. For multiple actuator arrangements, sum the input HP requirement of all actuators. If using mitre gear boxes, allow for 2% power loss through each 90° turn in the power path.
Considering capacity, speed, and duty cycle requirement, select the actuator type and configuration which most closely matches your application's configuration requirements.
Upright Translating Inverted Translating Upright Rotating Inverted Rotating
If your application involves a load which is un-attached or the load is free to rotate, the translating screw actuator must be configured so that the lifting screw will extend when the actuator is in motion. To prevent the translating screw from rotating, machine screw actuators are supplied with a keyed shell and screw, and ball screw actuators are supplied with a square nut on the lifting screw's end, inside a square cover pipe. Both of these configurations ensure the actuator will properly perform for this type of application.
Anti-Rotation Ball Screw Keyed Machine Screw
Double check your application's travel requirements, and the actuator's ratio. Verify the actuator's capacity and speed. Also, determine which of the following actuator end fittings best suits your application's requirements.
Top Plate Clevis End Threaded End
Please refer to our "Column Strength Charts" (pages 98 thru 102) if the lifting screw is loaded in compression. It may be necessary to select a larger actuator if the maximum recommended screw length, regardless of load, or maximum load has been exceeded.